Traditions carries both genuine vintage and vintage-style items. I’ve found a couple of things to be a bit overpriced (check out the Halloween Dolls–there’s a witch you can get for $20 at Tuesday Morning), but they carry a ton of stuff I haven’t seen anywhere else. They organize things into artist collections, so you know who did what. I also kinda love how it’s all on one enormous page. You just keep scrolling…
(note: all the links go to the main page, as there aren’t individual item pages)