House of Mysterious Secrets is the place to go for horror collectibles. Just look at their enamel pin section.
Creature from the Black Lagoon Pin, $9.99
They are particularly dedicated to classic and VHS-era horror.
Prom Night Earrings, $9.99
Free Hugs shirt, $17.99
BRB, I think I need a deck of Labyrinth playing cards.
Groovy post. Thank you!